In today’s educational settings, a new wave of teachers is redefining traditional teaching methods, introducing innovative strategies that reflect the changing needs and behaviors of modern students. This transition, fueled by technology and a fresh perspective on student engagement, significantly alters how classes are conducted and managed. Reddit, a popular online forum, has brought this issue to the forefront, provoking a lively discussion among students and educators. Are these novel approaches a necessary adaptation to our changing world, or do they risk compromising the foundational principles of effective teaching?

Woman shrugging
✅ AI Essay Writer ✅ AI Detector ✅ Plagchecker ✅ Paraphraser
✅ Summarizer ✅ Citation Generator

Key Takeaways:

  • Educators are increasingly required to balance innovative teaching methods with traditional educational practices.
  • Modern teaching methods are evolving in response to technological advancements and shifts in societal norms. 
  • Regardless of changes in teaching techniques, adhering to ethical teaching standards and professional principles remains crucial.

Teaching in Transition

The Reddit post has become the focus of a wider conversation about the evolution of teaching techniques. The post invites the audience to report the most unusual activities they’ve witnessed new teachers or administrators perform in the classroom, generating a rush of answers ranging from the inventive to the bold. This simple question has produced a multitude of viewpoints, revealing a dramatic shift in pedagogical techniques, particularly among new teachers.

These reactions reflect larger cultural and technical developments. Today’s learners, digital natives who grew up in the age of smartphones and social media, bring with them a distinct set of expectations and behaviors to the classroom. As a result, some new instructors are experimenting with approaches that deviate from established conventions in an attempt to bridge the gap between traditional education and the dynamic, tech-driven world in which their students live.

This change in teaching styles is not just about technology, but it also reflects evolving societal values. There’s a growing emphasis on fostering independence, encouraging critical thinking, and nurturing a more relaxed and open classroom environment. These trends are visible in teachers’ accounts who have tried to discard rigid structures in favor of more flexible and student-centric approaches.

However, as the Reddit post reveals, this evolution is not without its challenges. The stories shared by seasoned educators often highlight a learning curve for these new methods, with many new teachers facing resistance or unexpected consequences when trying to implement radical changes.

New Age Teaching: Innovation or Mistake?

Younger educators increasingly adopt unconventional classroom methods, influenced by rapid technological advancements and significant societal changes. This new wave of teaching, while innovative, raises questions about its efficacy and sustainability compared to traditional educational practices.

One Reddit user shared an experience with a new teacher who exemplified this shift: 

“There’s one brand-new teacher in my school who is ‘the cool teacher’ and told me they let the students be on their cell phones at all times. I’ve heard they’re having trouble now and trying to pull it back, and getting a lot of resistance.”

This is an example of a common theme among these novel approaches – an initial appeal that may eventually lead to unforeseen challenges.

A photograph of three students using cellphones
Image source:

Another student commented on the grading policies of a novice teacher, reflecting a significant departure from traditional methods, where not every task is necessarily graded, but rather some are used as learning experiences.

“Grading everything ‘because if I don’t make it for a grade they won’t try’. Anyone who goes down that route will eventually burn themselves out.” 

These modern approaches often originate from a desire to make the classroom more relatable and engaging for students. The integration of technology and more relaxed rules are seen as ways to connect with a generation of students who are immersed in a digital world. However, as some Reddit responses suggest, these methods can sometimes backfire, leading to classroom management issues and a decline in the overall effectiveness of teaching.

One teacher recounts the story of a colleague who embraced an extremely tolerant pass policy:

“The worst was the new teacher that had a ‘come and go as you please’ pass policy. At one point, this teacher had 14/17 students out and unaccounted for.” 

The need for a certain level of oversight and organization in collaborative learning scenarios is a cornerstone of all teaching methods, which is proven by another user who describes the consequences of a laissez-faire approach to group work: 

“Letting group work happen without assigning groups, monitoring the students, or making sure the phones are put away. You know… chaos and anarchy.”

A particularly daring instance involves conflict resolution, as shared by a Reddit user: 

“I know of a 1st-year teacher who was sick of trying to separate two kids always wanting to fight… He held those two in for lunch… Locked the door and told them to actually fight it out in class.”

Although the situation didn’t escalate, this radical approach to conflict management starkly contrasts with established disciplinary practices, raising questions about appropriate boundaries in handling student behavior.

These records provide a firsthand look at the outcomes of unconventional teaching methods. While some of these strategies might have been implemented with the best intentions, their real-world applications often reveal significant drawbacks. The experiences shared by all kinds of discussion participants highlight the importance of measured, experienced-based approaches in education. Through these accounts, it becomes evident that while innovation in teaching is necessary and often beneficial, it must be balanced with the wisdom and proven practices of traditional education. 
By comparing these new methods with time-tested traditional practices, a critical question arises: Are these innovative approaches truly enhancing the learning experience, or are they simply well-intentioned experiments that compromise the foundational teaching principles? 

The Unbreakable Code: Teaching Ethics and Standards

In education, certain fundamental principles stand as non-negotiable, forming an unbreakable code that guides teachers regardless of evolving methodologies and educational trends. These key principles, based on ethics and professional standards, are crucial for good and responsible teaching. Even as we try new and innovative ways of teaching, it’s important to remember that some practices are essential, and others should be avoided because they don’t fit with these principles.

Based on actual stories from teachers on Reddit, here’s a table that shows the difference between new teaching practices that are acceptable and those that go against the basic rules of good teaching:

✅ Acceptable Practices❌ Unacceptable Practices
Integrating technology for enhanced learningAllowing unrestricted use of cell phones
Encouraging group work and collaborationFailing to monitor group dynamics and progress
Adapting teaching methods to student needsCompletely discarding structured classroom management
Fostering an environment of open dialogueAllowing students unchecked freedom, leading to chaos
Implementing a variety of assessment methodsGrading every single task, leading to teacher burnout
Promoting critical thinking and independenceNeglecting guidance and support in the pursuit of autonomy
Recognizing and respecting diverse learning stylesIgnoring established disciplinary procedures in conflict resolution


The teaching world is rapidly changing like everything else. These changes bring fresh ideas and approaches, but they also present challenges. The key takeaway is the importance of balancing innovative techniques with the fundamental aspects of traditional teaching.

Adapting to new methods is crucial in today’s education. Yet, it’s equally important to uphold the tried-and-true practices that have consistently proven effective in teaching. The experiences shared by students and teachers remind us that, despite the changes in teaching methods, the primary goal of education—creating a supportive and effective learning environment—should always be our main focus.

Opt out or Contact us anytime. See our Privacy Notice

Follow us on Reddit for more insights and updates.

Comments (0)

Welcome to A*Help comments!

We’re all about debate and discussion at A*Help.

We value the diverse opinions of users, so you may find points of view that you don’t agree with. And that’s cool. However, there are certain things we’re not OK with: attempts to manipulate our data in any way, for example, or the posting of discriminative, offensive, hateful, or disparaging material.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Register | Lost your password?