A New York Times opinion piece by Frank Bruni challenges the prevailing college rankings system and encourages students to prioritize personal fit over prestige. The Times’s new interactive tool helps students consider factors like affordability, potential post-graduation earnings, and academic programs when selecting a college.

Woman shrugging
✅ AI Essay Writer ✅ AI Detector ✅ Plagchecker ✅ Paraphraser
✅ Summarizer ✅ Citation Generator

Rethinking College Admissions: A Misguided Focus on Prestige

An insightful commentary in The New York Times recently exposed the limitations of the prevailing college rankings system, sparking a conversation around a more comprehensive evaluation of higher education institutions. Authored by Frank Bruni, the piece challenges the dependence on college rankings as a measure of educational excellence and advocates for a wider and more equitable approach.

DURHAM, N.C. – Duke University’s distinguished campus frequently lures high school students and their parents with its striking Gothic Revival architecture, fervent basketball supporters, and an exclusive 6% acceptance rate. However, many students find it difficult to express their reasons for selecting Duke beyond its notable ranking and reputation, which they assume will shape their future accomplishments and contentment.

The overemphasis on prestige and rankings, exemplified by the contentious U.S. News & World Report, is misplaced. Students often overlook more relevant criteria when choosing a college, an issue Times Opinion’s new interactive tool aims to tackle. This platform encourages students to envision their ideal college experience, factoring in elements like affordability, potential post-graduation earnings, and academic programs.

Recent surveys by The Times and Morning Consult disclosed that young people aged 16 to 30 regard affordability and earnings after graduation as the most critical factors in their college experience. This innovative tool empowers students to prioritize these factors and identify colleges that resonate with their values and preferences.

In an effort to minimize the focus on rankings, some universities have taken bold steps. In 2023, Yale and Harvard announced that their law schools would no longer take part in the U.S. News rankings, with several other top-ranked law and medical schools following suit.

The Times’s interactive tool presents students with an opportunity to delve into the wide spectrum of colleges available, facilitating more informed decisions based on their individual preferences and values. Alongside this tool, students may also find resources such as admission essay examples helpful in understanding what schools are looking for in applicants. Yet, the college admissions process culture persists in prioritizing prestige over personal fit, resulting in students applying to an excessive number of schools. 

During their interview with Bruni, two current Duke students, Sophie Riegel and Mia Meier, revisited their college experiences and questioned the importance they had previously attached to attending a prestigious institution. They advised high school students to focus on cultivating self-esteem and nurturing their passions beyond college ambitions.

Despite the growing acknowledgment of the importance of personal fit in college selection, a significant number of high school students still fixate on enrolling in elite institutions. It is imperative to shift the college admissions process’s focus towards finding the right match for each individual, safeguarding the true essence and promise of higher education.

When choosing a college, students, and families should take into account the following key factors:

Academic programs

Evaluate if the college offers majors, minors, or concentrations that correspond to your academic interests and career objectives.

Campus culture and environment

Examine the campus vibe, extracurricular activities, clubs, and organizations to see if they align with your preferences.


Weigh the geographic location, climate, and neighboring community, and consider their potential impact on your college experience.

Financial aid and affordability

Analyze tuition fees, financial aid packages, scholarships, and work-study opportunities to assess each institution’s affordability.

Graduation rates and student outcomes

Study graduation rates, job placement rates, and average starting salaries to gauge an institution’s success in helping students achieve their goals.

Class size and faculty interaction

Reflect on the average class size, student-to-faculty ratio, and opportunities for research, mentorship, and collaboration with faculty members.

Diversity and inclusivity

Scrutinize the diversity of the student body, faculty, and staff, and the institution’s dedication to fostering an inclusive and nurturing environment.

Housing and campus facilities

Investigate the standard and availability of on-campus housing, dining options, and recreational facilities.

Study abroad and internship opportunities

Explore the range of study abroad programs, internships, and other experiential learning opportunities that align with your interests and aspirations.

Support services

Research the availability of academic support, career services, mental health resources, and disability accommodations to ensure you will have access to the necessary support throughout your college experience.

Related articles:

UC San Diego Students Reveal the ‘Worst’ Classes: A Candid Look at Course Experiences on Reddit

Admission professional assessed AI-generated essays and claimed they stood no chances at any top colleges

Bill Gates and educators urge students to master ChatGPT and other AI tools as an indispensable skill for the future

Opt out or Contact us anytime. See our Privacy Notice

Follow us on Reddit for more insights and updates.

Comments (0)

Welcome to A*Help comments!

We’re all about debate and discussion at A*Help.

We value the diverse opinions of users, so you may find points of view that you don’t agree with. And that’s cool. However, there are certain things we’re not OK with: attempts to manipulate our data in any way, for example, or the posting of discriminative, offensive, hateful, or disparaging material.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Register | Lost your password?