For generations, a college degree has been seen as the golden ticket to a successful career. Parents, educators, and society at large have emphasized the importance of higher education as a means to secure a prosperous future. The plan has been clear: go to college, get a degree in any field you like, and you’ll be set for life. But as the world evolves, is this strategy still accurate? More and more students are questioning their chosen academic paths, each with their own valid reasons. This tendency is evident in a Reddit post where a user expresses concerns about remaining competitive in the job market after graduation.

Woman shrugging
✅ AI Essay Writer ✅ AI Detector ✅ Plagchecker ✅ Paraphraser
✅ Summarizer ✅ Citation Generator

Key Takeaways:

  • While specializing is essential, having a diverse skill set can open up more opportunities.
  • Before pursuing higher degrees, gain work experience in your field.
  • Stay updated on the current and projected job market trends to make informed decisions about your education and career.
  • A stable job might offer more long-term benefits than a high-paying but unstable one.

The allure of certain professions, driven by their perceived prestige and lucrative returns, often leads to a surge in the number of students pursuing related degrees. Computer Science (CS) and Information Technology (IT) are prime examples of this phenomenon. Not so long ago, these fields were hailed as the future of work, promising high salaries and abundant opportunities. However, as more and more individuals flocked to these domains, the market started showing signs of oversaturation, and there are a few evident reasons of this phenomenon. 

Rapid Technological Advancements: The tech world is notorious for its rapid pace. New programming languages, tools, and methodologies emerge frequently. Sometimes by the time students graduate, some of the skills they learned might already be outdated. This constant evolution means that professionals need to be lifelong learners, continuously updating their skills to stay relevant. For those who don’t, the industry can quickly leave them behind.

Globalization: In our interconnected world, companies are no longer restricted to hiring talent from their immediate vicinity. Many roles, not only in IT, are now outsourced to countries where labor is cheaper. This has led to a competitive global job market, where candidates from across the world vie for the same positions, often willing to work for lower wages.

Automation and AI: The rise of automation and artificial intelligence has been both a boon and a bane. While they’ve led to increased efficiency and the creation of new types of jobs, they’ve also rendered many traditional roles obsolete. For instance, routine IT tasks that once required human intervention can now be automated, reducing the demand for certain job profiles.

Changing Market Dynamics: Sometimes, the job market shifts due to factors beyond technological advancements. For instance, when choosing a major, a field might seem promising, but market dynamics might have shifted by graduation. The IT sector, for example, has seen a shift from general IT roles to more specialized ones like cybersecurity or data science. As another Reddit user highlighted, generalized degrees can make it harder to secure job offers, as employers seek candidates with specific, transferable skills.

“I think the more generalized the degree, the more difficult it is to turn it into a job offer. Doesn’t matter if it’s STEM or Arts. Employers tend to be looking for people who can hit the ground running and there are so few true entry level jobs where they are willing to teach you everything from the ground up. So any education that teaches you marketable skills that are directly transferrable along with relevant student internships is going to be where it’s at.”

The Bubble Effect: This pattern is observed in many industries, not just IT. When a field becomes ‘trendy’, there’s a rush to join it, leading to a bubble. This bubble, when it bursts, leaves many struggling. For instance, the housing market crash of 2007-2008 is a testament to what happens when too many people chase after the same dream without considering the long-term implications.

Career Concerns in a Dynamic World

A Reddit user seems to have captured all these job market peculiarities and tries to think ahead. The user, currently pursuing a second degree in business administration focusing on supply chain and logistics, has been observing a trend that’s becoming all too familiar. They wrote,

“I’ve been seeing a lot of posts of those who have MBAs or degrees in IT/IS who can’t find jobs. Are these jobs becoming more compacted, the market fizzling out, or what? I try to keep my skillsets as diverse as possible but I’m kinda wondering if my current degree will be worthless.”

The user’s background as a supplier analyst with five years of experience adds weight to their concerns. They are not a fresh graduate but someone with industry experience, making their apprehensions all the more relatable to many in similar positions. Their decision to address the Reddit community for career advice underlines the value of collective wisdom in uncertain times. Platforms like Reddit have become modern-day forums where individuals seek guidance, share experiences, and offer insights to peers navigating similar challenges.

The nature of the user’s situation lies in the unpredictability of the job market. While they have taken steps to diversify their skills, the looming question remains: Will it be enough? The uncertainty of investing years in education only to face an oversaturated or changing job market is a concern shared by many. This modern-day quandary stresses the importance of not just academic pursuits but also the ability to adapt, learn continuously, and stay informed about industry trends.

Diverse Perspectives on Career Choices

The Reddit community is a melting pot of diverse experiences and perspectives. It offers invaluable insights into the evolving job market and can teach a way more helpful lesson than any career or academic advisor. Drawing from the top comments on the post, we can glean a deeper understanding of the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead for today’s graduates.

Experience Over Education

One of the most quoted ideas is the priority of work experience over academic qualifications. As one user insightfully pointed out, 

“You’re thinking about it backwards. An undergrad degree is often required for HR to tick the box. That’s a given. After that, it’s all about experience.”

The importance of gaining practical experience and not merely accumulating degrees is important. The user further advises against pursuing higher degrees like an MBA without first gaining some industry experience, emphasizing that “piling on degrees with no work experience will not help you get a good job.”

Stable Fields with Future Potential

Certain industries requiring a great deal of human involvement will forever be in demand. As the world continues to develop, the need for human expertise and touch in various sectors remains irreplaceable. Several users pointed out fields that are currently in need and are likely to remain so in the foreseeable future. One user mentioned highlighting the enduring value of human skills and knowledge in an increasingly automated world,

“We have a massive shortage of engineers such as civil, mechanical, structural, and construction managers. These cannot be replaced by any sort of AI.” 

AI, by the way, received its fair share of criticisms from users, pointing out the perceived exaggeration surrounding AI’s capabilities, especially by those marketing their software products. It accentuates the necessity of high-quality data for AI to be effective, noting that many businesses currently grapple with poor data quality. 

“AI is extremely overhyped by people trying to sell their questionable software. Even then, you need good data to feed into the AIs and data quality in many enterprises is TERRIBLE. Half you job as a data guy is fixing that up and an AI is not gonna be able to do that for a long time.”

The Role of MBAs and IT Degrees

While MBAs are seen as valuable for those aiming for management roles, understanding the nuances of the field you’re managing is crucial. Another user shared, “MBAs are good for those who go into management, which will never go away. But, you need to understand what your team does to manage them well.” The same user also highlighted the varying prospects within the IT sector, noting that while jobs in network and cybersecurity are booming, positions in applications programming and database administration are hard to fill with qualified people.

Most and Least Employable Degrees According to Reddit

A Forbes study was cited emphasizing the employability of certain degrees: “the three most employable degrees are Law, Medicine, and Foreign Language (this one especially if you have a double major in business or international studies).” This suggests that while STEM and business degrees are valuable, there’s also a significant demand for professionals with expertise in foreign languages, especially when combined with other skills. 

STEM field
Image source:

While the discussion primarily centered on promising fields, there were also warnings about degrees that might not offer the best job prospects. Humanities, art, and social science degrees are often mentioned as those that will unlikely guarantee the same job security as their STEM or business counterparts. The major reasons include the following:

Market DemandThe modern job market, especially in the private sector, often prioritizes roles that directly contribute to technological advancement, business growth, and revenue generation. STEM and business degrees are more directly aligned with these priorities
Tangible SkillsSTEM and business degrees often provide specific, tangible skills that have direct applications in various industries. For instance, a computer science degree might lead to a software development role, while a finance degree could lead to a position in investment banking. In contrast, humanities and social science degrees often impart broader, more abstract skills, which, while valuable, might not have as clear a path to specific job roles.
Rapid Technological ChangeThe pace of technological change has led to a surge in demand for professionals who can develop, manage, or work with new technologies. This has naturally favored STEM fields.
Economic FactorsIn times of economic downturn, roles that are considered “non-essential” might be the first to face cuts. Unfortunately, positions related to humanities, arts, or social sciences can sometimes fall into this category.
Perception of ROIThe rising cost of higher education has led students and parents to prioritize degrees that are perceived to offer a higher return on investment (ROI). STEM and business degrees, with their direct paths to higher-paying jobs, often seem to promise a better ROI.
SpecializationWhile STEM and business fields have numerous specializations that cater to specific industries (e.g., biomedical engineering, financial analytics), humanities and social sciences are often broader, which can make it harder for graduates to position themselves for specific roles.
Cultural EmphasisModern culture, especially in the age of startups and tech giants, places a significant emphasis on technological innovation and entrepreneurship. This can overshadow the contributions of humanities and social sciences.
Quantifiable ResultsBusinesses often prioritize roles that produce quantifiable results. While the value of critical thinking, cultural understanding, and ethical considerations (often the domain of humanities and social sciences) is undeniable, it’s harder to measure than, say, the development of a new software application or an increase in sales.


The world of work is constantly in flux, shaped by technological advancements, global trends, and societal shifts. While a college degree remains a valuable asset, it’s clear that the path to career success is no longer linear. The insights from the Reddit community underline the importance of adaptability, continuous learning, and practical experience in today’s job market. As industries evolve and new ones emerge, pivoting, upskilling, and staying informed become critical. Whether you’re a fresh graduate or a seasoned professional, the key lies in balancing academic qualifications and real-world skills, always staying attuned to the changing tides of the job market. In this dynamic landscape, it’s not just about what you know but how you apply it, adapt, and grow.


Opt out or Contact us anytime. See our Privacy Notice

Follow us on Reddit for more insights and updates.

Comments (0)

Welcome to A*Help comments!

We’re all about debate and discussion at A*Help.

We value the diverse opinions of users, so you may find points of view that you don’t agree with. And that’s cool. However, there are certain things we’re not OK with: attempts to manipulate our data in any way, for example, or the posting of discriminative, offensive, hateful, or disparaging material.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Register | Lost your password?