In the world of high school learning, kids are using AI tools to help them with assignments more and more often. Although not in every instance using helpers like ChatGPT entails completely ripping of work, but it doesn’t really matter for most of the teachers, since the work wasn’t done by the student entirely.

Woman shrugging
✅ AI Essay Writer ✅ AI Detector ✅ Plagchecker ✅ Paraphraser
✅ Summarizer ✅ Citation Generator

Key Takeaways:

  • AI tools offer students innovative ways to enhance their learning, but over-reliance can hinder genuine skill development and lead to potential plagiarism.
  • The moral debate around AI’s role in education is significant, with many arguing that students miss out on authentic learning experiences and critical thinking when they lean too heavily on these tools.
  • While AI detection can help educators identify AI-assisted work, these tools can misidentify genuine student efforts, causing unintended consequences and mistrust in the system.

In the dynamic world of education, high school students are discovering innovative tools to enhance their learning, and artificial intelligence (AI) stands out prominently among them. AI, once a concept confined to sci-fi movies, is now accessible through apps and online platforms, reshaping the way students approach their studies. From personalizing learning paths in mathematics to offering instant feedback on essay drafts, AI adapts to individual needs, ensuring a tailored academic experience. One of the Reddit users shared a post with the community about the fact that their daughter was blamed by the teacher for using ChatGPT to write her homework. However, the parent highlights the fact that this popular tool was used exclusively to structure the work and not put any thought for the student.

However, while the advantages are numerous, it’s essential to approach these tools with a discerning mind. As students embrace the digital age and its offerings, they are learning not just from AI, but also about the responsibility that comes with using it. This exciting frontier in education holds potential, and high schoolers are at the forefront of exploring its possibilities. But sometimes it can result in serious consequences.

How Many Students Actually Use AI to Write?

In modern classrooms, the use of artificial intelligence (AI) by students to craft essays and complete assignments is on the rise. AI-driven platforms offer tools that can help generate ideas, correct grammar, and improve overall content quality. 67 percent of high school students utilize AI tools, like chatbots, to assist in composing essays or finishing school assignments. Students find these tools particularly useful in expediting the writing process and ensuring higher accuracy. Based on recent findings, more than half of students admitted they will still use tools like ChatGPT even if their institution will directly prohibit it.

However, there’s a thin line between assistance and over-reliance. While AI can enhance writing, it’s crucial for students to maintain originality. Relying too heavily on AI might compromise the development of genuine writing skills, and in some cases, even lead to plagiarism issues. As with all tools, using AI responsibly is key.

The Moral Implications of Using AI as a Homework Helper

Using AI to help with homework isn’t as straightforward as it seems. Sure, it’s tempting to get quick answers, but are we missing out on real learning? There’s a moral side to consider. When we lean too much on AI, we might lose our ability to think deeply or solve problems on our own. It’s a bit like peeking at the answers at the back of a textbook. And honestly, doesn’t it feel better when we figure things out ourselves? As technology grows, we need to chat more about where to draw the line, especially in school.

Most Reddit users under the original thread jumped into the discussion and blamed it entirely on the parent. The main reason behind such a negative reaction was that the parent was enabling their daughter to work less when doing her homework.

“I think by letting your kid use ChatGPT to “write” for her, you’re doing her a disservice. It’s a shortcut to producing better (and more coherent and cohesive) writing. Did your daughter learn to be a better writer and sentence-crafter by copy/pasting her assignment into ChatGPT?”

“Lol. This is hilarious. You’re attacking a teacher for doing their job? You did your kids homework with her is one point that may be a factor here and then you used an online tool to restructure it, this is essentially rewriting it. You and your kid got caught, you’re doing her no favours by attacking the system that caught her. You’re teaching her a very unhelpful life lesson here.”

Other users stressed the fact that the teacher most probably drew a conclusion from the student’s other work, which was significantly lower in quality, to notice such a change. 

“The teacher is familiar with the quality of your daughters work. She can compare the answers to your daughters past work & this improved work quite easily and see the difference in structure & language. At the very least, you’re going to need a parent-teacher conference.”

“I’m a teacher and I’d do the same – those words are not reflective of her actual work – the grade reflects that. Want your daughter to write better or not?”

Wrapping it up, AI tools might be nifty, but they can’t replace the good old grind of learning. Leaning too much on them might just steal away genuine learning moments from students. The buzz on Reddit clearly paints the picture: there’s a thin line between using tech for help and over-relying on it. As cool as these tools are, they shouldn’t replace hard work. So, as we march ahead with tech, let’s ensure it aids our growth, not stunts it. After all, there’s no app for the satisfaction of figuring things out on our own, right?

The Issue of AI Detection 

The rise of AI has brought many benefits, but it also raises concerns, especially in the area of AI detection. As more students turn to AI tools to aid in their schoolwork, educators are grappling with how to detect such assistance. Just like plagiarism tools spot copied content, there’s a growing need for tools to detect AI-generated writing. However, most, if not all of those tools, can give false results, so that a human-written text will be flagged as AI and vice versa.

One of the users highlighted the fact that AI detection is often faulty and unless there is direct and undeniable proof that the assignment was created by ChatGPT completely, there is not much the teacher can do.

“It’s NOT possible to detect AI generated writing. NONE of those detectors work. You can paste in work untouched by GPT and it’ll say it’s AI or Vice Versa. Admit nothing and Start there.”

To wrap things up, while using AI can make tasks easier, it does have a flip side in the education world. Just like how sometimes our phones autocorrect to the completely wrong word, AI detectors in schools can also get it wrong. It’s tough for students who genuinely tried when they’re wrongly flagged for cheating. As we keep mixing technology and learning, we need to get the balance right. It’s like blending the right ingredients in a recipe. Teachers and tech folks should team up, making sure these tools help students without causing unnecessary stress or mistrust.


Opt out or Contact us anytime. See our Privacy Notice

Follow us on Reddit for more insights and updates.

Comments (0)

Welcome to A*Help comments!

We’re all about debate and discussion at A*Help.

We value the diverse opinions of users, so you may find points of view that you don’t agree with. And that’s cool. However, there are certain things we’re not OK with: attempts to manipulate our data in any way, for example, or the posting of discriminative, offensive, hateful, or disparaging material.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Register | Lost your password?