Selecting a college with countless factors in play can make the decision process feel overwhelming. But what if you have two equally beneficial opportunities and you just can’t decide? A Reddit thread with a similar question triggered a discussion on whether the person should choose a paid scholarship or spend a coin on so-called “better” education.

Woman shrugging
✅ AI Essay Writer ✅ AI Detector ✅ Plagchecker ✅ Paraphraser
✅ Summarizer ✅ Citation Generator

Key Takeaways:

  • Choosing the right college is more than just about the institution’s reputation; it’s about aligning with future career goals and personal growth opportunities.
  • Despite the perceived prestige of certain universities, where you study as an undergraduate may not significantly affect certain career outcomes or advanced education admissions.
  • It’s crucial for students to evaluate colleges based on their individual needs, desired field of study, and the overall value and experiences the institution offers, rather than solely on its reputation.

Choosing a college is not just about selecting an institution for higher education; it’s about choosing a path for one’s future. It’s a decision that carries the weight of shaping career trajectories, molding personal growth, and influencing networks and relationships for years to come. With a myriad of factors to consider – from financial aspects and location preferences to academic excellence and extracurricular opportunities – the process can be both exciting and frustrating. 

It all started when a Reddit user raised an interesting question about college selection based on merit-based aid. They noted that certain universities, such as the University of Alabama, Mississippi State, and the University of South Carolina, offer substantial scholarships, sometimes even a full ride, to students who showcase stellar GPAs and test scores. In contrast, prestigious institutions like Johns Hopkins or Duke don’t provide the same kind of merit-based aid.

Obviously not having to pay a dime sounds amazing but for someone interested in med school, will going to the better undergrad mean higher acceptance to better med schools?

OP contemplated the pros and cons, stating that while attending college for free sounds enticing, they wondered if attending a top-tier undergrad institution would increase their chances of getting into a renowned medical school.

The most upvoted comment shared their personal experience. The Redditor opted for a full-ride at a T100+ university rather than attending a T10, aiming to conserve funds for law school. They flourished at their chosen college, securing a national scholarship that substantially reduced their T10 law school fees. 

“I loved my college, did very well there, and won a national scholarship that I used to pay a significant chunk of my T10 law school tuition.”

Despite the commenter’s husband having attended an Ivy League for his undergraduate studies, they both advise their high-achieving children to consider in-state options or seek merit scholarships at out-of-state universities. But where does it leave us?

Free Ride Is the Most Appealing Option for Most

Choosing the right college can be tricky. Sure, the name and prestige of a school might sound impressive, but that doesn’t mean it’s the best fit for everyone. While a well-known university might have its perks, it’s vital for students to think about what they really want from their college experience. Are those fancy schools going to help them reach their dreams and career goals? 

Accept a Paid Scholarship in Average College vs Pay for a Better University? Redditors Discuss

Matt Lopez, executive director of Admission Services at Arizona State University stresses the fact that it’s super important for students to pick a place where they feel they’ll thrive and get the support they need, rather than just going for a school because it has a big name. After all, it’s all about finding the right fit and what feels right for the individual. 

When it comes to medical school admissions, there are key factors that play a pivotal role, many of which are directly within a student’s control. Primarily, the emphasis is placed on overall GPA, the GPA in specific pre-med courses such as Biology, Chemistry, Organic Chemistry, and Physics, and the MCAT score. Interestingly, while many might believe the name or prestige of an undergraduate institution would carry significant weight, it often has minimal impact on the admission process. The comments under the original post seem to share this narrative.

“The college you attend will have very little effect.”

The dilemma of choosing between prestigious institutions and more affordable educational options is a common crossroads many students face. Another user also shared their story in response to the original post, where they opted for a state school that offered a full-ride scholarship, along with an honors program, instead of choosing a more prestigious institution. Upon graduation, they secured their dream job.

“I was in this position 15 years ago, and I picked the full ride at a state school, with an honors program. I ended up with my dream job straight out of college. We actually hired someone from the more prestigious school I was accepted at, and he had the exact same title as me and was earning the same salary, so I made it to the exact same spot but with no debt.”

So, as you can see, when it comes to costly tuition, most people would probably choose to go to a less prestigious university (which is also a relative term), if it meant they would be less financially restrained. Prestige doesn’t always ensure a 100% quality of education, unfortunately, so maybe opting for a free-ride scholarship is the safest option out of the two.

The Choice Isn’t Universal for Various Fields

Choosing the right college depends a lot on what job you want in the future. If you want to be a doctor, it might be a good idea to go to a famous and expensive college because they offer better training and connections. This can help when looking for jobs later. On the other hand, if you want to work in hospitality and manage a hotel, it’s more about the skills you learn and the real work experience you get. Going to a big-name school might not be as important. Instead, internships and hands-on training can be more valuable. So, students should think about what skills and experiences they need for their dream job and pick a school based on that.

Honestly, it depends on my major and what kind of field of work I’m planning on heading into post graduation. Becoming a teacher? State School is fine. Those loans take a lifetime to pay off, and schools are always in need of more teachers. Becoming a brain surgeon? John Hopkins it is. Prestige is real when it comes to high paying jobs, and paying off loans isn’t too bad when you’re making 150K+ per year working in an industry with a high quality of life.

Another commenter shared the same sentiment, once again bringing up the issue of prestige education and what “higher-end” colleges might help you with.

Really depends on what you wanna do post college. If you’re interested in going directly into the workforce and want “prestigious” jobs in business like investment banking or consulting, it helps to go to a T25.”

Although the question of picking a school is daunting as it is, the responsibility of facing the consequences still lies on your shoulders. That is precisely why you should approach this issue with a cold head and a significant amount of self-reflection.

Points to Consider When Choosing a College

Choosing the right university is like picking your future path. Today, with so many schools out there, making the best choice can seem very hard, especially just after high school. Many students go by feelings or pick based on only a few things, sometimes just a gut feeling. But, it’s important to think deeply before deciding. M.N.I Niro, CEO of International Centre for Integrated Studies, highlighted several factors to consider when you’re stuck choosing a university.

First of all, think about your personal reasons. Why do you want to go to college? Even if you don’t know what job you want later, you know what you like now. This can help you pick the kind of courses or the general direction you might like, be it arts or more technical stuff. Apart from that, make sure the college you like is accredited. Being accredited means the school follows generally accepted academic rules, making sure you get a good education.

Most of the common points people tend to think about when choosing a place to study for the next few years include finances. College is costly, especially in the United States. It’s key to look at the price, available help, and what you get for your money. While private schools might cost more, they often give out money to help students pay for tuition. One of the Redditors in the thread mentioned above shared their opinion on this aspect:

Unless your parents are literal millionaires with full financed retirement, I would take that full ride all the way to the bank. If the parents did have some funds for UG hopefully they’d be willing to hold it for grad/med school.”

Considering a variety of subjects is also important, even if they don’t seem like a good fit for you at first. You don’t need to pick a specific subject now, but having a general idea is helpful. This ensures that you don’t join a school that doesn’t have what you might want to study later. Still, many schools let students pick their major subjects later, giving them time to think. The same goes for career opportunities. Rankings give a quick look at how good a school is, but they don’t tell everything. Still, famous schools can help you get a job more easily later on.

The size of the school (well, not literally) also matters a whole lot. Big colleges often come with a lot of resources. This might mean better on-campus things like places to live, libraries, computers, health spots, sports areas, and even places for fun and culture. Big schools that focus on research usually spend a lot on their teachers, classroom tools, and labs, especially for subjects like computer science and engineering. On the other hand, small colleges have their own special things that big ones don’t. Some prefer to stay small to focus on teaching arts or specific subjects in depth. The campuses tend to be more close-knit, with fewer students in classes, making the whole feel of the place more personal and close.

Moreover, we shouldn’t forget about activities outside classes. Joining clubs, creating your own groups, participating in events, and doing other fun things can make your college years better and help you learn in different ways. Hence, it’s necessary to check out the extracurriculars and the quality of student life overall in your potential future place of study.

And last but not least is geographic location, even though it may seem silly to many people. Where the school is matters a lot. Whether you see yourself in a busy city or a quiet campus, where you are will shape your college life.

In the end, while picking a university may seem tough, taking time to think about these things can make it clearer. The process of looking at options and finding the best fit can also help you learn more about yourself.


Opt out or Contact us anytime. See our Privacy Notice

Follow us on Reddit for more insights and updates.

Comments (0)

Welcome to A*Help comments!

We’re all about debate and discussion at A*Help.

We value the diverse opinions of users, so you may find points of view that you don’t agree with. And that’s cool. However, there are certain things we’re not OK with: attempts to manipulate our data in any way, for example, or the posting of discriminative, offensive, hateful, or disparaging material.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Register | Lost your password?